History of Purdens Purple

[Psalms441]

Hello,
I have been looking around on the Internet for the history of Prudens Purple. There is no name credited to the person who created or donated this tomato. All that is said is that it is related to Brandywine. Any history on this tomato in here?

[carolyn137]

Originally Posted by Psalms441

Hello,
I have been looking around on the Internet for the history of Prudens Purple. There is no name credited to the person who created or donated this tomato. All that is said is that it is related to Brandywine. Any history on this tomato in here?

No,it is not related to Brandywine.That came about when Prudens Purple was listed at Pinetree seeds many years ago and referred to it as an early Brandywine

http://tatianastomatobase.com/wiki/Pruden%27s_Purple

It is not know who first named it Prudens Purple or where it was first found. In the SSE Yearbooks there was a huge argument b/c one person was saying the correct name was Prudence Purple and said so and so named it that way.

If I had the time I could go back to my earlier SSE Yearbooks and try to pull up more info,but honstly,I just don't have the time.

All to say is that it's,IMO,an excellent variety.

Carolyn

[Psalms441]

Thank you Dr. Carolyn. I have some of those seeds and will try next spring. It was jut a mystery to me where it's origins came from.

[Jonnyhat]

these were the pride and joy of my garden last year.... Dear Prudens....

[AlittleSalt]

Thank you Carolyn, you just explained why I have read it called by both names. I just planted two Pruden's Purple today for our fall garden. Now, I know it is truly named Pruden's Purple.

[Gardeneer]

adjective
adjective: prudent
acting with or showing care and thought for the future.

Prudent as adjective to "purple" sounds more relevant than "prudence". JMO

But , anyway it sounds like something to grow. I might add it to my 2017 grow list for more than one reason : First being tasty ; Second being early ..
Gardeneer

[My Foot Smells]

Interesting query and informative reply. Is it safe to say that seeds are true from all vendors and what governs seed sellers. Seems like there could be some discrepancy off the beaten path.

[carolyn137]

Originally Posted by My Foot Smells

Interesting query and informative reply. Is it safe to say that seeds are true from all vendors and what governs seed sellers. Seems like there could be some discrepancy off the beaten path.

Not just for Prudens Purple, but any variety,IMO you cannot be sure of what you are getting from most seed vendors. Those that do their own growouts and seed saving are perhaps the best.Those that contract out or buy seed wholsale often have problems.

Back at the original Garden Web I used to do a thread each year asking about wrong varieties and where they came from and what folks did about it.

I was surprised to find that many never reported wrong varieties b/c they were too embarrassed to do so.

Again IMO, there are some seed sources I trust much more than others and no,I'm not going to list them here since there will never be consensus.Over the years I've participated at many different message sites and I feel confident in saying that the highest percentage of wrong varieties comes from traded seeds.

And there were always problems when an individual stated they got wrong seeds for X seed CO,reported it, and their computer records showed that the person never had bought seeds from them.Sometimes such persons would post and say they were wrong,sometimes not.

Carolyn

[AlittleSalt]

I think it is just someone's first or last name Pruden - Example - John Pruden or Pruden Smith.

Then add an 's to Pruden making it a possessive noun.

Pruden's meaning a purple tomato someone named Pruden named after them self = Pruden's Purple.

[Gardeneer]

Originally Posted by AlittleSalt

I think it is just someone's first or last name Pruden - Example - John Pruden or Pruden Smith.

Then add an 's to Pruden making it a possessive noun.

Pruden's meaning a purple tomato someone named Pruden named after them self = Pruden's Purple.

Sound logical explanation , to me, Robert.

Prudent's Purple (tomatoa)

Gardeneer

[My Foot Smells]

My aunt has/had a seed bank for medicinal plants that she grew organically. Interns usually worked the farm over the summer and were seed collecting labor. Screened boards and often very tedious with small seeds. Often time late teen, early 20 something's doing a summer stint. I have gathered many a seed for the operation and admit, I lose patience and focus - but also admit I have adult onset ADHD - a very severe case of it!!

So, I'm sure some might thing this whole thing is like a lab experience with strict QC, but probably not. Then again, I've worked in a few QC labs where high IQ couldn't tie shoe.

[Tormato]

To this day, I still label it Prudence Purple.

Not to rile up Carolyn ( I know not to strike a hornet's nest), but maybe someone searching for the "correct" name (either is good enough for me), if there is a correct name, will find it.

Now if I remember correctly , Carolyn, you've said the first listing in the SSE was Prudence Purple. About the only other thing I "may" remember was the donator's name sounded Scottish, and was from from PA or somewhere thereabouts.

What I do remember the most, is that Prudence Purple is the earliest of the "superb" tasting tomatoes in my garden. Pruden's Purple is ripe a few minutes later.

Gary

P.S. Carolyn, if I did rile you up, please have me confused as one of the other Garys.

[carolyn137]

Originally Posted by Tormato

To this day, I still label it Prudence Purple.

Not to rile up Carolyn ( I know not to strike a hornet's nest), but maybe someone searching for the "correct" name (either is good enough for me), if there is a correct name, will find it.

Now if I remember correctly , Carolyn, you've said the first listing in the SSE was Prudence Purple. About the only other thing I "may" remember was the donator's name sounded Scottish, and was from from PA or somewhere thereabouts.

What I do remember the most, is that Prudence Purple is the earliest of the "superb" tasting tomatoes in my garden. Pruden's Purple is ripe a few minutes later.

Gary

P.S. Carolyn, if I did rile you up, please have me confused as one of the other Garys.

Gary,it was first SSE listed as Prudens Purple, and then came along this other person who said it should be called Prudence Purple,and that started the argument.

aha, my 1993 SSE Yearbok just appeared so I can give you that info.

I was correct in saying that it was first listed as Prudens Purple.

An SSE member from Indiana then said that it should be Prudence Purple, and he got the seeds from a Mr McLaughlin who said he would be listing it as Prudence,rather than Prudens and that he should do the same.He got seeds from an older gent in Charleston,IL who spelled it that way.

In that 1993 Yearbook there were many listings for Prudens but very few for Prudence.

In the 2016 SSE Yearbook there are many listings for Prudens,and just ONE listing for Prudence.

If you want to continue listing it as Prudence,that's up to you,but from what I've just shared with you I know I wouldn't.

About riling me up Gary.I've got lots of other issues to get riled about these days viz my current health problems.

Carolyn

[jtjmartin]

Prudens Purple is a huge showoff in my garden this year - thick stems, plenty of blooms, and getting close to topping the 5 foot CRW cage! Wow! Prudens loves Virginia!

Thanks to Tormato for the MMMM swap where I got the seeds.

[garyjr]

Originally Posted by jtjmartin

Prudens Purple is a huge showoff in my garden this year - thick stems, plenty of blooms, and getting close to topping the 5 foot CRW cage! Wow! Prudens loves Virginia!

Thanks to Tormato for the MMMM swap where I got the seeds.

5' already?.. That is impressive. I have 2 in the ground nearing 3 feet that look great and 2 still in pots that I am trying to find a home for.