Brandywine Sudduth vs. Ed's Millennium ... and (My) Winner is...

rnewste · July 17, 2008

I'm now harvesting large quantities of fruit and fortunately, both Brandywine Sudduth and Ed's Millennium have decided to join the party.

Ed's Millennium weighed in at 17.6 ounces and the Brandywine came in at 9 ounces.

In terms of texture and seeds - both are quite similar. While both tasted good to me, the Ed's had a more pronounced flavor, similar to my Earl's Faux. The Brandywine on the other hand, was a bit more "mild", and less "wow".

Again as Carolyn says, everyone's palate is unique, however I won't be devoting garden space to Brandywine Sudduth next year, but will be doubling my Ed's Millennium in its place.

Ray

July 17, 2008	#1
rnewste Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Campbell, CA Posts: 4,064	Brandywine Sudduth vs. Ed's Millennium ... and (My) Winner is... I'm now harvesting large quantities of fruit and fortunately, both Brandywine Sudduth and Ed's Millennium have decided to join the party. Ed's Millennium weighed in at 17.6 ounces and the Brandywine came in at 9 ounces. In terms of texture and seeds - both are quite similar. While both tasted good to me, the Ed's had a more pronounced flavor, similar to my Earl's Faux. The Brandywine on the other hand, was a bit more "mild", and less "wow". Again as Carolyn says, everyone's palate is unique, however I won't be devoting garden space to Brandywine Sudduth next year, but will be doubling my Ed's Millennium in its place. Ray