One last crack at Brandywine.

where_with_all · April 5, 2007

Brandywine sudduth is tops for me too. I do taste tests with lots of people (>30) and do head on comparisons. BW Sudduth edged out Marianna's Peace last year by a statistically significant margin. Usually caveats apply- my soil-my area- my growing conditions.

This year, if I can ever get my BW to sprout, I will be comparing them to Earls Faux. Again over 30 people will taste and provide opinions.

I can not wait. Rapature is a very strong word for eating tomatoes. I would not turn away any tomatoes.. but BW, IMO, and in the opinion of my crackerjack panel, tastes ever so slightly better than others (thus far!)

April 5, 2007	#16
where_with_all Tomatovillian™ Join Date: May 2006 Location: Long Island NY Posts: 152	Brandywine sudduth is tops for me too. I do taste tests with lots of people (>30) and do head on comparisons. BW Sudduth edged out Marianna's Peace last year by a statistically significant margin. Usually caveats apply- my soil-my area- my growing conditions. This year, if I can ever get my BW to sprout, I will be comparing them to Earls Faux. Again over 30 people will taste and provide opinions. I can not wait. Rapature is a very strong word for eating tomatoes. I would not turn away any tomatoes.. but BW, IMO, and in the opinion of my crackerjack panel, tastes ever so slightly better than others (thus far!) __________________ Where With All on Long Island