Recommend what you consider an acidic tomato

[BigVanVader]

Super Sioux and Celebrity come to mind.

[ginger2778]

Originally Posted by jpop

Not sure but have technically have 2 growing seasons, so can try in both, thank you.

More like one 9-10 month long one!

MarNarF6 is very rich, balanced not sweet at all, lovely huge tomatoes, pretty nice production too. Can't remember, was that one of your seed requests from my offer?

[joseph]

I would definitely not recommend Green Zebra... Because it tastes way to acidic to me. And I like acidic foods!

[dokutaaguriin]

Another vote for Silvery Fir Tree

[jpop]

Fantastic feedback, thank you. I should clarify a little more. I am looking more for a tangy than tart tomato, so more balanced than say sour/tart. So it sounds like green zebra may not be to my liking. Looking for a tangy zing punch to an overall good tomato. I know clear as mud. Silvery Fur Tree sounds like another good option.

[jpop]

Originally Posted by ginger2778

More like one 9-10 month long one!

MarNarF6 is very rich, balanced not sweet at all, lovely huge tomatoes, pretty nice production too. Can't remember, was that one of your seed requests from my offer?

Good point Marsha, 1 long growing period is actually more accurate, although I have always heard it referred to as 2 seasons. Possibly because of the long duration as you mentioned, resulting in fall, winter, and spring, and also that it is between 2 calendar years.

I did not request the MarNarF6, but now wish I had. Maybe next year.

[dfollett]

Silver Fir Tree - and for a yellow, Azoychka.

[cecilsgarden1958]

Only one I can think of is Bonny Best.

[Hunt-Grow-Cook]

Originally Posted by jpop

Fantastic feedback, thank you. I should clarify a little more. I am looking more for a tangy than tart tomato, so more balanced than say sour/tart. So it sounds like green zebra may not be to my liking. Looking for a tangy zing punch to an overall good tomato. I know clear as mud. Silvery Fur Tree sounds like another good option.

An edible option with some serious zip and flavor in my garden is Berkley Tie Dye and Pink Berkley Tie Dye. Rebel Yell also has a nice punchy zip, but still balanced and flavorful. Probably more along the lines of what you are looking for.

[Andrey_BY]

Most of early red fruited tomato varieties are acidic.

[Gardeneer]

Originally Posted by dfollett

Silver Fir Tree - and for a yellow, Azoychka.

Agree. I have grown both of them.
Azoychka is a vigorous indet while SFT is a very compact determinant, fit to grow in a 4-6 gallon container. It is also very early.

Gardeneer

[jmsieglaff]

I'll put a kinda different thought out there--if you like cherries, try Sungold at the yellow stage. Depending on when you pick and eat them you can get quite different experiences. My least favorite stage (well aside from green) would be super-ripe, because they lose that unique tangy zip and are more just sweet to me.

[jpop]

I do also enjoy cherry and other smaller tomatoes, provided they are good. I was lucky enough to get some seeds for Rebel Yell from Marsha in the SASE she recently offered. Definitely would give Berkley tie die a shot as well. Thanks all, keep em coming.

[walt456]

if you are open to small tomatoes most of the currants I've tried fit what you're looking for.

[Sun City Linda]

I enjoy tomatoes with some acid and I like Druzba, Siux, Silvery Fir Tree and Old Brooks JUST FINE