Kelloggs Breakfast vs. KBX - Page 2

Hairy Moose Knuckles · January 31, 2008

I just posted a request for this variety if anyone has a few seeds that need a good home.

Tomstrees · January 31, 2008

I'm curious:
has anyone had an RL plant pop up from starting KBX seed?

~ Tom (who is def. on the orange PL good flavor bandwagon)

Fusion_power · January 31, 2008

While not specific to KBX, I regularly find regular leaf seedlings mixed among my potato leaf tomatoes. I also find other leaf form variants that are clearly the result of crosspollination. For example, I have Aunt Ginny's Purple in my growout this year that is producing about 3 regular leaf plants per 100 seedlngs. I also have a single plant of Silvery Fir Tree that is obviously crossed based on leaf form.

Crosses happen folks. The important thing is to recognize them and decide if you want to save the resulting seed. I have some very interesting crosses in advanced stages of dehbridizing. They are here because I recognized a chance cross in my seed flats or in my garden.

DarJones

gardenmama · January 31, 2008

Tom-

In growing out KBX for the past 5 seasons I have had the odd RL plant occur. When I first discovered what I named KBX (short for Kellogg's Breakfast Unknown if Crossed) back in 2002 it was because a package of Kellogg's Breakfast had a 50/50 grow out of RL and PL.

April 2002, Kellogg's Breakfast on (L) - KBX on (R)

My curiosity was piqued and I just had to see what would happen if I grew out the PL plants. I kept it to myself for a couple of seasons to see if the saved seeds grew out true to form and had the same amazing taste as they did in 2002. They did and I took a fruit or two to Tomatopalooza [tm]III in 2005. Craig tasted it and went back for seconds, Jerry spooned up seeds to take back to Ohio, several others asked for seeds and KBX was off and running.

**carolyn137** · January 31, 2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by gardenmama

Tom-

In growing out KBX for the past 5 seasons I have had the odd RL plant occur. When I first discovered what I named KBX (short for Kellogg's Breakfast Unknown if Crossed) back in 2002 it was because a package of Kellogg's Breakfast had a 50/50 grow out of RL and PL.

April 2002, Kellogg's Breakfast on (L) - KBX on (R)

My curiosity was piqued and I just had to see what would happen if I grew out the PL plants. I kept it to myself for a couple of seasons to see if the saved seeds grew out true to form and had the same amazing taste as they did in 2002. They did and I took a fruit or two to Tomatopalooza [tm]III in 2005. Craig tasted it and went back for seconds, Jerry spooned up seeds to take back to Ohio, several others asked for seeds and KBX was off and running.

Martha, you forgot that you and I were both still posting on AOL, my we've known each other for a long time, LOL, and you first described it there and you were also distributing seeds there as well.

I honestly can't remember if I got some seeds from you back then, or not.

amideutch · February 1, 2008

I would just like to thank gardenmama again as she was kind enough to share seeds with me as well. So, to all that I have shared KBX seeds with she was my source and originator if you will. Ami

PaulF · February 1, 2008

Yes, thank you Martha. I got mine two years ago and side-by-side with KB, KBX has performed very well. In size, production and taste (my family taste ratings) KBX was on average bigger, grew more tomatoes per plant and rated half a point higher on flavor than KB. We appreciate your work.

JerryL · February 1, 2008

Martha’s correct.

I spooned up seeds to bring back to Ohio and have been growing it ever since.

I’ve always gotten PL plants with terrific tasting fruit. Actually, I’ve stopped growing Kellogg’s Breakfast because KBX performs so much better for me.

Tomstrees · February 1, 2008

hmmmm - I wonder what the RL plants would have produced ... ~ Tom

gardenmama · February 1, 2008

Tom-

The RL plants from the 50/50 packet grew out orange beefsteaks as well. However they didn't produce as heavily and went down to disease, from what I can recall, almost 6 weeks earlier than the PL plants, which produced until frost.

Gardeneer · February 26, 2019

Interesting.
I was doing a google search on KB and came across with this 11 year old thread. Might bring back memories for some of you.
My Story
I got some seeds of KB donated , few years ago.
I planted seeds last year year but did not germinate. I did not givel up.
So I planted again this year. I was getting disappointed. Most my other,seeds,germinated in 4 to 6 days. But it took Kb TEN days. Finally got couple out of a,bunch of them.
I suspect that,the seeds that I got were of poor quality. OR MAYBE this is a characteristics of KB?!

Now I know that KBX is a better choice. But it does not matter too much to me a s I am not interestemd in a big crop.
What i like,about it is taste, size, color and shape.

seaeagle · February 26, 2019

I am growing Kellogg's Breakfast for the first time too. i can't understand how anything would be different in regards to taste, production and disease resistance. Shouldn't they both be identical in growing habit if there was no crossing?

I guess the disease part could be explained by potato leaf plant getting better air circulation. Anyway will see what happens

DonDuck · February 26, 2019

i grew KB for a few years. I then started growing KB and KBX. For me, in my hot summer climate; the KBX was slightly superior in all categories but highly superior in taste, fruit size; and production.

I invite people to visit my garden. I focus on red tomatoes, but make sure I have a few KBX in the garden for people to notice as they wander around. I wait for the question "what is this?". Most people are not aware a fully ripe tomato can be orange in color. I make sure they have some large ones to take home as gifts with instructions to tell me what they think after tasting them. I wait for the phone call or email. Everyone seems astounded that an orange tomato can have that "old time" tomato flavor.

The KBX was the first variety to germinate under lights this year. It seems all the planted seeds germinated and the seedlings have been growing so fast that I am concerned they may be exhibiting hybrid vigor in growth. They are already double the height of the other varieties under identical growing conditions.

seaeagle · February 26, 2019

I searched a few tomato sites and seed sellers. Some say all is the same, some say one is better than the other and some say it is a cross. The consensuses seemed to be that the taste was the same but KBX was more productive.

JosephineRose · February 26, 2019

I did a test trial side by side last year. My KB produced fewer, smaller fruit and went down hard and fast to disease. KBX kept going into November.

January 31, 2008	#17
Tomstrees Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: NJ Bayshore Posts: 3,848	I'm curious: has anyone had an RL plant pop up from starting KBX seed? ~ Tom (who is def. on the orange PL good flavor bandwagon) __________________ My green thumb came only as a result of the mistakes I made while learning to see things from the plant's point of view. ~ H. Fred Ale

January 31, 2008	#19
gardenmama Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: zone 7b/8a SE VA Posts: 268	Tom- In growing out KBX for the past 5 seasons I have had the odd RL plant occur. When I first discovered what I named KBX (short for Kellogg's Breakfast Unknown if Crossed) back in 2002 it was because a package of Kellogg's Breakfast had a 50/50 grow out of RL and PL. April 2002, Kellogg's Breakfast on (L) - KBX on (R) My curiosity was piqued and I just had to see what would happen if I grew out the PL plants. I kept it to myself for a couple of seasons to see if the saved seeds grew out true to form and had the same amazing taste as they did in 2002. They did and I took a fruit or two to Tomatopalooza [tm]III in 2005. Craig tasted it and went back for seconds, Jerry spooned up seeds to take back to Ohio, several others asked for seeds and KBX was off and running. __________________ -Martha SE VA

February 1, 2008	#21
amideutch Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Germany 49°26"N 07°36"E Posts: 5,041	I would just like to thank gardenmama again as she was kind enough to share seeds with me as well. So, to all that I have shared KBX seeds with she was my source and originator if you will. Ami __________________ Life's journey is not to arrive at the grave safely in a well preserved body, but rather to skid in sideways, totally worn out, shouting ‘...Holy Crap .....What a ride!'

February 1, 2008	#22
PaulF Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Brownville, Ne Posts: 3,296	Yes, thank you Martha. I got mine two years ago and side-by-side with KB, KBX has performed very well. In size, production and taste (my family taste ratings) KBX was on average bigger, grew more tomatoes per plant and rated half a point higher on flavor than KB. We appreciate your work. __________________ there's two things money can't buy; true love and home grown tomatoes.

February 1, 2008	#23
JerryL Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: S.W. Ohio z6a Posts: 736	Martha’s correct. I spooned up seeds to bring back to Ohio and have been growing it ever since. I’ve always gotten PL plants with terrific tasting fruit. Actually, I’ve stopped growing Kellogg’s Breakfast because KBX performs so much better for me. __________________ Jerry

January 31, 2008	#16
Hairy Moose Knuckles Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Zone 8 Texas Posts: 172	I just posted a request for this variety if anyone has a few seeds that need a good home.

January 31, 2008	#18
Fusion_power Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Alabama Posts: 2,250	While not specific to KBX, I regularly find regular leaf seedlings mixed among my potato leaf tomatoes. I also find other leaf form variants that are clearly the result of crosspollination. For example, I have Aunt Ginny's Purple in my growout this year that is producing about 3 regular leaf plants per 100 seedlngs. I also have a single plant of Silvery Fir Tree that is obviously crossed based on leaf form. Crosses happen folks. The important thing is to recognize them and decide if you want to save the resulting seed. I have some very interesting crosses in advanced stages of dehbridizing. They are here because I recognized a chance cross in my seed flats or in my garden. DarJones

February 26, 2019	#26
Gardeneer Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Feb 2015 Location: NC - zone 8a - heat zone 7 Posts: 4,919	Interesting. I was doing a google search on KB and came across with this 11 year old thread. Might bring back memories for some of you. My Story I got some seeds of KB donated , few years ago. I planted seeds last year year but did not germinate. I did not givel up. So I planted again this year. I was getting disappointed. Most my other,seeds,germinated in 4 to 6 days. But it took Kb TEN days. Finally got couple out of a,bunch of them. I suspect that,the seeds that I got were of poor quality. OR MAYBE this is a characteristics of KB?! Now I know that KBX is a better choice. But it does not matter too much to me a s I am not interestemd in a big crop. What i like,about it is taste, size, color and shape. __________________ Gardeneer Happy Gardening !

February 26, 2019	#27
seaeagle Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Oct 2014 Location: virginia Posts: 743	I am growing Kellogg's Breakfast for the first time too. i can't understand how anything would be different in regards to taste, production and disease resistance. Shouldn't they both be identical in growing habit if there was no crossing? I guess the disease part could be explained by potato leaf plant getting better air circulation. Anyway will see what happens

February 26, 2019	#28
DonDuck Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Dec 2017 Location: Corinth, texas Posts: 1,784	i grew KB for a few years. I then started growing KB and KBX. For me, in my hot summer climate; the KBX was slightly superior in all categories but highly superior in taste, fruit size; and production. I invite people to visit my garden. I focus on red tomatoes, but make sure I have a few KBX in the garden for people to notice as they wander around. I wait for the question "what is this?". Most people are not aware a fully ripe tomato can be orange in color. I make sure they have some large ones to take home as gifts with instructions to tell me what they think after tasting them. I wait for the phone call or email. Everyone seems astounded that an orange tomato can have that "old time" tomato flavor. The KBX was the first variety to germinate under lights this year. It seems all the planted seeds germinated and the seedlings have been growing so fast that I am concerned they may be exhibiting hybrid vigor in growth. They are already double the height of the other varieties under identical growing conditions. Last edited by DonDuck; February 26, 2019 at 03:38 PM.

February 26, 2019	#30
JosephineRose Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Feb 2016 Location: California Posts: 383	I did a test trial side by side last year. My KB produced fewer, smaller fruit and went down hard and fast to disease. KBX kept going into November.