Sungold Replacement

[Al@NC]

Thanks Marsha, your opinion matters a lot to me! That price is pretty good but I only grow 1 plant a year so that would take a while to go through .

Have you tried to find a cherry better than Sungold before?

Al

[peebee]

I got tired of Sungold in recent years even though it is good; for the past 2 years I have grown Blush as a sort of replacement even though perhaps it is not technically cherry-shaped. Everyone around me who has tasted it loves it.
Maybe I will grow SG next year but it just produces so many cherries that one plant is way more than enough for us.

[KarenO]

Originally Posted by ginger2778

Are you certain it's OP?

Nothing is certain but death and taxes.

[KarenO]

Marsha and I are going to make the best cherry going. Give us time and good KARMA.
KarenO

[MissS]

SunGold is offered in the MMMM that Tormato put on every year. It's any easy way to get a hold of a few seeds for those looking for it, all that you have to do is participate in the swap and request a few seeds.

KARMA.............Sigh

[Al@NC]

Thanks for the info MissS! I'm planning on participating in it next year, I was too late this year.

I didn't know Sungold was offered there. Reading the responses here shows me how popular Sungold is and I thought that there would be more people that have replaced it but I guess it really is that good.

I'll probably just keep buying my 1 plant at the nursery each year!

@Karen, I'm another PNW'er that's excited about your new varieties, and can't wait to try them!

Al

[Father'sDaughter]

I caved in to all the hype and asked for a few Sungold seeds through the MMMM this year. I haven't grown a single hybrid since my first venture into growing tomatoes about five years ago.

[MissS]

Originally Posted by Father'sDaughter

I caved in to all the hype and asked for a few Sungold seeds through the MMMM this year. I haven't grown a single hybrid since my first venture into growing tomatoes about five years ago.

Well......... Your in for a treat!

[Al@NC]

I haven't grown Big Beef F1 before so I'm not locked into growing it but I am Sungold F1. I might have to try Big Beef F1 next season as well.

I don't know how or why I quickly adopted a anti-hybrid attitude, my first tomatoes were burpee Steak Sandwich F1 before finding T-ville!

Al

[Fred Hempel]

I think that simplistically, opponents of GMOs, Big Ag et al. often feel the need to divide the world into "good things" and "bad things" and hybrids (since many are used in Big Ag, and created by Big Seed) have been deemed "bad".

It is not hard to find people 100% against hybrids, that are only too willing to proclaim that for any hybrid there is a similar (if not better) OP variety. Sometimes this is true. Some times it is fiction. And, of course, not all hybrids are created by Big Seed or for Big Ag.

Originally Posted by Al@NC

I haven't grown Big Beef F1 before so I'm not locked into growing it but I am Sungold F1. I might have to try Big Beef F1 next season as well.

I don't know how or why I quickly adopted a anti-hybrid attitude, my first tomatoes were burpee Steak Sandwich F1 before finding T-ville!

Al

[Fred Hempel]

The idea that one "must" be able to dehybridize SunGold, and select an equivalent line has led to lots and lots of mediocre tomatoes being grown.

Sometimes hybrids are delicately balanced, and the parents synergistic. And SunGold is a pretty good example of that.

What if everyone trying to dehybridize and re-select SunGold had been working on developing unique varieties?

[Father'sDaughter]

I'm not anti-hybrid, I just don't like being "dependent" on a variety for which seeds must be purchased. I've had too many much-loved products discontinued by manufacturers over the span of my lifetime.

I guess I'm afraid I'll fall in love with some hybrid variety and then the seeds will be discontinued and I will spend the rest of my growing years obsessively searching for something comparable. I'm like that.

[heirloomtomaguy]

Originally Posted by Father'sDaughter

I'm not anti-hybrid, I just don't like being "dependent" on a variety for which seeds must be purchased. I've had too many much-loved products discontinued by manufacturers over the span of my lifetime.

I guess I'm afraid I'll fall in love with some hybrid variety and then the seeds will be discontinued and I will spend the rest of my growing years obsessively searching for something comparable. I'm like that.

I can almost guarantee Sun Gold F1 will never be discontinued. The company that produces it may go out of business which is unlikely but possible as in any business. But Sun Gold F1 is to amazing for them to stop producing it.

[Karma]

Hi,

I also grow Sungold every year and love it. I didn't think I could love a tomato more than Sungold. A few years back I was at a tomato tasting and tried Orange Paruche. Everyone went nuts. It looks just like a Sungold and the flavor is similar but it has an extra something that truly makes it taste even better. This year I didn't plant any Sungold which I never thought I would do and instead planted 4 Orange Paruche. It is a winner for sure.

Happy Gardening!

Karma

[RJGlew]

Originally Posted by Fred Hempel

I think that simplistically, opponents of GMOs, Big Ag et al. often feel the need to divide the world into "good things" and "bad things" and hybrids (since many are used in Big Ag, and created by Big Seed) have been deemed "bad".

It is not hard to find people 100% against hybrids, that are only too willing to proclaim that for any hybrid there is a similar (if not better) OP variety. Sometimes this is true. Some times it is fiction. And, of course, not all hybrids are created by Big Seed or for Big Ag.

Thanks Fred - it is good when someone with your cred stands up and provides a reasoned opinion like this.