Bobcat versus Big Beef?

Cole_Robbie · January 1, 2015

The new Territorial catalog has Bobcat. I was looking at it and wondering if anyone has grown both Bobcat and Big Beef together and can compare them? I don't like most hybrids, so I'm skeptical of new ones, but I do like Big Beef. Both it and Bobcat were developed by the same company, Syngenta.

If Bobcat has the flavor of Big Beef, it looks very promising. But if it tastes like a typical market grower hybrid, I don't want it.

MikeInCypress · January 4, 2015

Bobcat is determinate or semi determinate while Big Beef is indeterminate.

MikeInCypress

Cole_Robbie · January 4, 2015

And that's largely why I'm interested in it. I'm thinking it would be good for early and late plantings. My Big Beef keep setting fruit all year, but they get tiny by the end of the season.

I just wonder if Bobcat tastes similar to Big Beef. I hate growing varieties that I don't think taste good.

zero244 · January 10, 2015

I cant answer your question since I have not grown ether one. I was considering getting some Big Beef seeds myself and decided to order some Grandaddy seeds.
It is a Det Hybrid as well. But I thought is looked promising and it is a Det.
Grandaddy seems very close to Big Beef without the indeterminate growth habit.

Cole_Robbie · January 10, 2015

Someone on the gardenweb forums told me they grew Bobcat and did not like the flavor at all. They said it was not anything like Big Beef. I will probably pass.

Salsacharley · January 10, 2015

Why not grow one or two Bobcat just to see how it works for you? That wouldn't be much risk.

RJGlew · January 10, 2015

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cole_Robbie

...but I do like Big Beef. Both it and Bobcat were developed by the same company, Syngenta.

Big Beef Hybrid was Colen Wyatt from Seminis Seed.

Cole_Robbie · January 10, 2015

sorry. I get Seminis and Syngenta mixed up.

RJGlew · January 10, 2015

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cole_Robbie

sorry. I get Seminis and Syngenta mixed up.

NP - credit where credit is due for a fantastic product. I always grow Big Beef F1, even though in some years I am lucky to ripen even a single one on the vine. 3A gardening sure stinks.

Can't be that bad, eh? Check out Jeff Casey's record of the 2014 growing season in photos/video at the very bottom of his page (he is also 3A, a few miles north of where I am):

http://www.caseysheirloomtomatoes.ca...Catalogue.html

Cole_Robbie · January 10, 2015

I like it a lot, too. I order 500 or so Big Beef seeds every spring. I tell market customers that it is the tomato to grow if they only grow one variety.

RJGlew · January 10, 2015

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cole_Robbie

I like it a lot, too. I order 500 or so Big Beef seeds every spring. I tell market customers that it is the tomato to grow if they only grow one variety.

That would be good advice - you are certainly doing them a favour. Are you a commercial grower, or selling as an individual at the market?

Cole_Robbie · January 11, 2015

I'm just a market vendor with my family. My grandparents started going when I was a kid, thirty years ago. One of these days, maybe I will get to call myself a commercial grower. I'm getting there...slowly.

Tapout · January 16, 2015

I to would like to find a non Monsanto big beef alternative with the same taste and resistances, but to this date I have found none. A few were on par with taste but not as resistant. I despise Monsanto and all they stand for, if Satan were to own a seed company it would be called Monsanto.

Cole_Robbie · January 17, 2015

I received some Big Beef OP seeds a few weeks ago in a swap. I look forward to trying them.

Tapout · January 20, 2015

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cole_Robbie

I received some Big Beef OP seeds a few weeks ago in a swap. I look forward to trying them.

I am going to go with the hybrid Big Beef this year, but I am interested in how well your OP variety turns out. Are you going to do a side by side comparison of the plants?

January 1, 2015	#1
Cole_Robbie Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jun 2012 Location: Illinois, zone 6 Posts: 8,407	Bobcat versus Big Beef? The new Territorial catalog has Bobcat. I was looking at it and wondering if anyone has grown both Bobcat and Big Beef together and can compare them? I don't like most hybrids, so I'm skeptical of new ones, but I do like Big Beef. Both it and Bobcat were developed by the same company, Syngenta. If Bobcat has the flavor of Big Beef, it looks very promising. But if it tastes like a typical market grower hybrid, I don't want it.

January 4, 2015	#2
MikeInCypress Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Cypress, TX Posts: 963	Bobcat is determinate or semi determinate while Big Beef is indeterminate. MikeInCypress __________________ "Growing older, not up"

January 10, 2015	#4
zero244 Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Apr 2014 Location: Oregon Posts: 47	I cant answer your question since I have not grown ether one. I was considering getting some Big Beef seeds myself and decided to order some Grandaddy seeds. It is a Det Hybrid as well. But I thought is looked promising and it is a Det. Grandaddy seems very close to Big Beef without the indeterminate growth habit.

January 10, 2015	#6
Salsacharley Tomatovillian™ Join Date: May 2013 Location: New Mexico Posts: 2,052	Why not grow one or two Bobcat just to see how it works for you? That wouldn't be much risk.

January 11, 2015	#12
Cole_Robbie Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jun 2012 Location: Illinois, zone 6 Posts: 8,407	I'm just a market vendor with my family. My grandparents started going when I was a kid, thirty years ago. One of these days, maybe I will get to call myself a commercial grower. I'm getting there...slowly.

January 16, 2015	#13
Tapout Tomatovillian™ Join Date: May 2012 Location: NW Indiana Posts: 355	I to would like to find a non Monsanto big beef alternative with the same taste and resistances, but to this date I have found none. A few were on par with taste but not as resistant. I despise Monsanto and all they stand for, if Satan were to own a seed company it would be called Monsanto.

January 17, 2015	#14
Cole_Robbie Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jun 2012 Location: Illinois, zone 6 Posts: 8,407	I received some Big Beef OP seeds a few weeks ago in a swap. I look forward to trying them.