Best of the potato-leaf varieties?

indigosand · April 24, 2013

I've found I have a soft-spot for these, "pink brandy-wine" is my absolute favorite. This year I've also planted "hillbilly". What other great potato-leaf varieties exist out there?

tam91 · April 24, 2013

Brandywine Sudduth's is considered by many to be the best pink Brandywine, and I think the original. I also love KBX potato leaf (an orange tomato). Captain Lucky also, a wonderful tri-color.

ginger2778 · April 24, 2013

Indian stripe PL, and Spudakee, which is Cherokee Purple
PL, and Lucky Cross is to die for!
Marsha

feldon30 · April 24, 2013

There are so many good pink potato leaf varieties. To name a few...

Earl's Faux
Terhune
Stump of the World
~~Hege German Pink~~

OOPS! Looks like Hege German Pink is not a PL.

travis · April 24, 2013

Brandywine-Sudduth for a pink, KBX for an orange (tangerine), Captain Lucky for a GWR-bicolor, Captain Lucky White for a pale cream yellow, Big Cheef for a purple, and for a red PL I'd say a particular recombination of Brandywine x Neves Azorean Red that remains unnamed at this time.

b54red · April 24, 2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by feldon30

There are so many good pink potato leaf varieties. To name a few...

Earl's Faux
Terhune
Stump of the World
Hege German Pink

Isn't Hege German Pink a regular leaf tomato?

tam91 · April 24, 2013

Oh yes, I'll vote for Terhune and Earl's Faux too.

Lucky Cross didn't blow me away, I prefer it's "child" Captain Lucky.

indigosand · April 24, 2013

Thanks! Taking notes! I'd love to hear more!

nancyruhl · April 24, 2013

Brianna
Earls Faux
Lincoln Adams
Lindas Faux
Lithuanian
Mariannas Peace
Pervaya Lyubov
Stump of the World
Summertime Gold
Terhune.

New varieties I am trialing this year
Bkx
Caseys Pure Yellow
Indian Stripe PL
Heshpole
Pamplemouse du Grand Pere
Rebel Yell
Wandas Potato Top
Weisnichts Ukranian
West Virgina Straw

A couple of varieties turned to potato leafs in my garden and I have continued to grow those out. Granny Cantrells and Purple Dog Creek. They seem much more vigorous.

roper2008 · April 24, 2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by ginger2778

Indian stripe PL, and Spudakee, which is Cherokee Purple
PL, and Lucky Cross is to die for!
Marsha

So, the Cherokee Purple PL I bought from Sandhill Preservation is Spudakee?

Stvrob · April 24, 2013

Im growing a PL that is just called plain "Brandywine" on the seed packet (from Johnny's). Is there a difference between this and Suddeth Brandywine or Pink Brandywine? This is my first year growing heirlooms and I was hoping I picked out something good.

Also, I don't see my other Potato Leaf, "Japanese Trifle", on anyone's list. I have lots of fruit set, but I've never tasted it so don't know what to expect.

JamesL · April 24, 2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by roper2008

So, the Cherokee Purple PL I bought from Sandhill Preservation is Spudakee?

Maybe so and maybe not. I think that is an argument that has never been settled.

**carolyn137** · April 24, 2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by roper2008

So, the Cherokee Purple PL I bought from Sandhill Preservation is Spudakee?

There are two Cherokee Purples that are PL. One was found by Jere Gettle and is called Cherokee Purple Potato Leaf, Spudakee was found and named by Bill Malin.

Are the two PL ones the same?

Several folks have grown both in the same year along with the original CP for comparison and there's differences of opinion on the difference between the two PL's and either one of the PL's and the original RL.

One can't just assume that a PL version of an original RL is the same except for leaf form b'c there are many kinds of mutations that can occur going from an RL to a PL.

If it's a single spontaeous mutation of one gene, OK, but there are other ways in which the DNA changes such as repeats, inversions, looping out, etc,, in which case more than one gene can be involved,

Which is why I, for one , never assume apriori that a PL versions of original RL's are the same except for a one gene mutation that changed only the leaf form/

I know, too much to post, but I'm here and I do have strong feelings about the issue.

Carolyn

travis · April 24, 2013

Jere Gettle's Cherokee Purple Potato Leaf was found in a garden in Missouri and is not the same as Spudakee which was found in a garden in Ohio.

indigosand · April 25, 2013

Wow, overwhelmed with information but in a good way! LOL I'm looking all these up. A nice purple would be great... I didn't have good luck with "carbon" last year.

I believe what I have is sudduth's strain. I've collected seed from this same plant so many years in row that I can't be sure anymore. It's amazing. I cooked burgers and made BLT's in honor of a freshly picked beauty many times last summer. LOL They are too good not to savor. I only wish the branches were a bit stronger. I had quite a few snap off from the sheer weight of a fruit set last year. If anyone has suggestions for that, I'm all ears.

Has anyone grown the one I keep coming across simply named "yellow brandywine"? Can you compare it to other yellows? I have dr. wyche's this year.

April 24, 2013	#1
indigosand Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Apr 2013 Location: california Posts: 99	Best of the potato-leaf varieties? I've found I have a soft-spot for these, "pink brandy-wine" is my absolute favorite. This year I've also planted "hillbilly". What other great potato-leaf varieties exist out there?

April 24, 2013	#2
tam91 Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Crystal Lake IL Posts: 2,484	Brandywine Sudduth's is considered by many to be the best pink Brandywine, and I think the original. I also love KBX potato leaf (an orange tomato). Captain Lucky also, a wonderful tri-color. __________________ Tracy

April 24, 2013	#4
feldon30 Tomatovillian™ Join Date: May 2006 Location: Rock Hill, SC Posts: 5,346	There are so many good pink potato leaf varieties. To name a few... Earl's Faux Terhune Stump of the World ~~Hege German Pink~~ OOPS! Looks like Hege German Pink is not a PL. __________________ [SIZE="3"]I've relaunched my gardening website -- [B]TheUnconventionalTomato.com[/B][/SIZE] * [I][SIZE="1"]*I'm not allowed to post weblinks so you'll have to copy-paste it manually.[/SIZE][/I]

April 24, 2013	#7
tam91 Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Crystal Lake IL Posts: 2,484	Oh yes, I'll vote for Terhune and Earl's Faux too. Lucky Cross didn't blow me away, I prefer it's "child" Captain Lucky. __________________ Tracy

April 24, 2013	#3
ginger2778 Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Aug 2011 Location: Plantation, Florida zone 10 Posts: 9,283	Indian stripe PL, and Spudakee, which is Cherokee Purple PL, and Lucky Cross is to die for! Marsha

April 24, 2013	#5
travis Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Evansville, IN Posts: 2,984	Brandywine-Sudduth for a pink, KBX for an orange (tangerine), Captain Lucky for a GWR-bicolor, Captain Lucky White for a pale cream yellow, Big Cheef for a purple, and for a red PL I'd say a particular recombination of Brandywine x Neves Azorean Red that remains unnamed at this time.

April 24, 2013	#9
nancyruhl Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Metro Detroit, Michigan Posts: 1,051	Brianna Earls Faux Lincoln Adams Lindas Faux Lithuanian Mariannas Peace Pervaya Lyubov Stump of the World Summertime Gold Terhune. New varieties I am trialing this year Bkx Caseys Pure Yellow Indian Stripe PL Heshpole Pamplemouse du Grand Pere Rebel Yell Wandas Potato Top Weisnichts Ukranian West Virgina Straw A couple of varieties turned to potato leafs in my garden and I have continued to grow those out. Granny Cantrells and Purple Dog Creek. They seem much more vigorous.

April 24, 2013	#11
Stvrob Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jan 2013 Location: Jacksonville, FL Posts: 1,413	Im growing a PL that is just called plain "Brandywine" on the seed packet (from Johnny's). Is there a difference between this and Suddeth Brandywine or Pink Brandywine? This is my first year growing heirlooms and I was hoping I picked out something good. Also, I don't see my other Potato Leaf, "Japanese Trifle", on anyone's list. I have lots of fruit set, but I've never tasted it so don't know what to expect.

April 25, 2013	#15
indigosand Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Apr 2013 Location: california Posts: 99	Wow, overwhelmed with information but in a good way! LOL I'm looking all these up. A nice purple would be great... I didn't have good luck with "carbon" last year. I believe what I have is sudduth's strain. I've collected seed from this same plant so many years in row that I can't be sure anymore. It's amazing. I cooked burgers and made BLT's in honor of a freshly picked beauty many times last summer. LOL They are too good not to savor. I only wish the branches were a bit stronger. I had quite a few snap off from the sheer weight of a fruit set last year. If anyone has suggestions for that, I'm all ears. Has anyone grown the one I keep coming across simply named "yellow brandywine"? Can you compare it to other yellows? I have dr. wyche's this year.